USERS OF OLD MAPS: RESEARCH TO COGNITIVE ASPECTS OF THE USE
OF OLD MAPS
E. Heere
Utrecht University, Faculty of Geosciences - Dept. of Human
Geography and Urban and Regional Planning
e.heere@geo.uu.nl
Last
decades modern technology, like GIS, has entered the field of historical
cartography. The use of these modern technologies leads to new questions about
the users of old maps: what do they expect from the new technologies, how do
they incorporate the technologies in their research projects or in which way
does the technology influence a research project. Users research will give
answers to these kind of questions.
In this
paper a research project is presented about the use and users of a GIS for
historical cartography.
The GIS
contains information from several estate atlases. These atlases, dated 1550
until 1840, contain handwritten property maps. The maps contain a lot of
topographical information, so they are a rich source for historians. A few
examples of these maps will be shown.
In, what we
normally call, ‘modern’ cartography there is a long history in users research.
Several methods were used by the researches, of which some are useful to the
research on the use of old maps. One of these methods, the think-aloud method,
is used in the research project, presented in this paper. With this method, the
subject (test person) has to fulfil some exercises. The subject is asked to
speak out loud all the thoughts he has. His talking, but also all of his
handlings, will be recorded on video- and audiotape. These tapes lead to a
‘verbal protocol’, which can be analysed. These verbal protocols provides us
information about the way a subject (in this case the professional user of old
maps) acts in performing a task, and, especially, why he acts the way he does.
The reasons for using this method will be further explained.
In this
paper the exercise which test persons had to fulfil will be explained and the
results of the tests will be presented.